Insights

Decision guide

SDR or account manager as your first sales hire?

When your first salesperson should be an SDR and when an account manager, and why coaching makes the difference in both cases.

6 min read · Updated 15 November 2026

IN SHORT

Hire an account manager first when there are already leads and conversations that nobody follows up properly. Choose an SDR when the problem sits at the front of the funnel and too few new conversations come in, provided someone in the company can coach that SDR every day. Without guidance and training, neither role gets off the ground.

As long as the founder closes every deal, the first sales hire feels like a big step. It is also the hire that shapes most how the sales team grows afterwards. The choice is usually between an SDR, who opens and qualifies new conversations, and an account manager, who runs those conversations and closes deals. Which role you need first depends on where your pipeline gets stuck.

When an SDR is the right first hire

An SDR fits when too few new conversations come in, while the founder or an experienced colleague closes the ones that do come in well. The bottleneck is then at the front. An SDR supplies those conversations, so the people who can close actually spend their time closing.

Do watch the preconditions. An SDR is usually junior, works at high volume and has to deal with a lot of rejection. Without someone who checks in daily, listens back to calls and adjusts, good starters often drop out within a year. It also has to be clear who the target group is and what counts as a qualified conversation, or the SDR fills the calendar with meetings that help nobody.

When an account manager fits better

An account manager is the better choice when there is already enough demand. You can tell by website leads that sit untouched for days, referrals from customers or partners that nobody follows up and proposals that stall because the founder has no time for them. An SDR adds little in that situation, because the problem lies in the follow-up.

An account manager can also do part of the prospecting. At an early stage that is often healthy, because the first salesperson gets to know the whole story, from first contact to signed contract. An experienced account manager often needs three to six months to get up to speed, and a starter usually needs longer.

Time, risk and knowledge

An SDR asks for a smaller investment in salary and a larger investment in coaching. First results can come sooner, often within two to three months, provided the target group and message are already clear. The risk lies in turnover. If the SDR leaves, you start over with recruiting and onboarding.

An account manager asks for a larger investment and a longer lead time, especially in markets with long sales cycles such as ERP or enterprise IT. In return, knowledge about customers, objections and deals comes together in one person. That is valuable, and it is also a risk if that knowledge is never written down. So agree from the first day that conversations, agreements and lessons go into the CRM.

A middle route

A middle route that often works well is to hire a starter who begins as an SDR and grows into an account manager within a year. In the first months that person opens conversations and sits in on the founder's meetings. After that they take over more and more themselves, first smaller deals and later the full cycle.

That path only works with a clear training plan. What should someone be able to do after three months, what after six, and who assesses that? Without that structure, the starter either stays too long in a role they have already outgrown or gets deals they are not ready for yet.

How to choose

Look at your pipeline over the past three months. If there are too few new conversations, start with an SDR and arrange daily coaching. If conversations and proposals are stalling, go for an account manager. If both are true, an account manager who also prospects is usually the safest first step.

Also take an honest look at who will coach the new colleague. A first salesperson has no peers to learn from and often no documented sales story yet. Without a fixed weekly moment to go through conversations with the founder or an experienced colleague, even a talented hire quickly loses their way.

At Live Sales we train starting salespeople in technology companies, from the first cold call to running a demo and following up on a proposal. In a sales office of fifty people we saw many starters begin and grow. If you are about to make your first sales hire, we are happy to help with the profile and the onboarding plan.

Want to put this into practice in your team?

Book a call

Related service Training and development →

READ NEXT

Training What works, and what doesn't, in an SDR's first 90 days

Forecast Why most forecasts are wrong, and what to do about it

Live Sales · Book an introduction